Best “American Horror Story” Character
In 2011, Ryan Murphy changed the game -- and freaked out TV audiences in a big way -- by launching FX Network's "American Horror Story." Since then, the horror anthology series has become appointment TV each fall, with seasons tackling demons, witches, aliens, vampires, political cults, serial killers, and anything else that might terrify and disturb. Along the way, the series has featured an impressive rotating cast of bonafide stars and notable character actors, many of whom have portrayed multiple iconic characters. Now, for our 2024 Halloween special, the Great Pop Culture Debate wants to determine the best "American Horror Story" character of all time. Characters discussed: Sister Mary Eunice (“Asylum”), Liz Taylor (“Hotel”), Lana Winters (“Asylum”), Montana Duke (“1984”), Misty Day (“Coven”), Cordelia Goode (“Coven”), Tate Langdon (“Murder House”), Constance Langdon (“Murder House”), Fiona Goode (“Coven”), Madison Montgomery (“Coven”/“Apocalypse”), James Patrick March (“Hotel”), The Countess (“Hotel”), Elsa Mars (“Freak Show”), Marie Laveau (“Coven”/“Apocalypse”), Sister Jude (“Asylum”), Myrtle Snow (“Coven”/“Apocalypse”).
Join host Eric Rezsnyak, GPCD panelists Karissa Kloss and Zack Derby, and special guest panelist Erin Marlow from It’s a Fandom Thing podcast as they discuss and debate 16 of TV’s most shocking characters.
Great Pop Culture Debate is brought to you by Factor Meals. Visit factormeals.com/greatpop50 and use the code greatpop50 for 50% off your first box plus 20% off your next month.
Play along at home by finding the listener bracket here. Make a copy for yourself, fill it out, and see if your picks match up with ours!
For more exclusive content, including warm-up in which we discuss the “AHS” characters we were bummed didn’t make the bracket, become a Patreon supporter of the podcast today.
Round 1 Match-Ups:
Not a Patreon subscriber? Here’s a primer on how we came up with the bracket.
Match-Up 1: Liz Taylor, “Hotel” (1) vs. Sister Mary Eunice, “Asylum” (4)
Match-Up 2: Lana Winters, “Asylum” (3) vs. Montana Duke, “1984” (2)
Match-Up 3: Misty Day, “Coven” (1) vs. Cordelia Goode, “Coven”/“Apocalypse” (4)
Match-Up 4: Tate Langdon, “Murder House” (3) vs. Constance Langdon, “Murder House” (2)
Match-Up 5: Fiona Goode, “Coven” (1) vs. Madison Montgomery, “Coven”/“Apocalypse” (4)
Match-Up 6: James Patrick March, “Hotel” (3) vs. The Countess, “Hotel” (2)
Match-Up 7: Marie Laveau, “Coven”/“Apocalypse” (1) vs. Elsa Mars, “Freak Show” (4)
Match-Up 8: Myrtle Snow, “Coven”/“Apocalypse” (3) vs. Sister Jude, “Asylum” (2)
Want to play along at home?
Download the Listener Bracket and see if your picks match up with ours!
Sign up for our weekly newsletter!
Subscribe to find out what’s new in pop culture each week right in your inbox!
Vote in more pop culture polls!
Check out our Open Polls. Your votes determine our future debates!
Then, vote in our Future Topic Polls to have a say in what episodes we tackle next.
Episode Credits
Host: Eric Rezsnyak
Panel: Karissa Kloss, Zack Derby
Special Guest Panelist: Erin Marlow, It’s a Fandom Thing Podcast
Producer: Bob Erlenback
Editor: Eric Rezsnyak
Theme Music: “Dance to My Tune” by Marc Torch
